Help me understand. In this film, the host goes around asking people 'what is a woman' and gets very mixed answers. From that, he draws a specific definition of a woman that doesn't match the data he just gathered. I don't think that's how science works
Help me understand. In this film, the host goes around asking people 'what is a woman' and gets very mixed answers...
The point was to mock the people who don't know what a woman is, and then tell them what a woman actually is.
I haven't seen it. Does he come up with an answer other than "an adult female" or is that the point?
He looks like a reddittor
asking random opinions
data
How can a word have an "actual" meaning that somehow doesn't match the meaning people assign to it?
So tell me what a woman is.
How else are you supposed to figure out the meaning of a word?
You're talking to Trumpublicans they don't understand the social reality of language. They think God created words that match perfectly onto reality.
Nah the best part is when he goes to Africa and asks tribal ooga boogas what a woman is, and they laugh at him. The tranny brigade has no answer for that, so he wins.
It's already been decided, the debate is over, not even sure why it's being brought up years later.
OMG THE BASED MASSAI NIGGERS FELLOW MIGAPEDES
lol yeah these guys are super civilized!
As a MAGA Trumper, is there anyone else who thinks Matt Walsh is a cringey ass pussy?
I can respect nazis, fascists, racists etc but only if they aren't pussies. I lost all respect for him when he couldn't tell Joe rogan why he was against fag marriage when all he had to say was
I'm a Catholic and it's part of my religious beliefs.
Instead he went on and fucking on trying to justify it in any way possible without just saying "I hate fags because I'm christian"
What is a Woman?
All the other stuff around a pussy
Are these the guys who only count up to 5, and anything beyond that is just 'a lot'?
a person of the opposite sex to a man who birthes children and breastfeeds them
Hope that helps, OP.
woman - is not a man,
man - is not a woman.
That really helped, thank you.
He goes around asking the question and getting circular answers like "a woman is anyone who says they're a woman" as well as hostile responses. Finally, at the end, he gets the best answer from his wife that a woman is an adult human female. Good documentary but Matt Walsh is a Shabbos Goy.
a woman is an adult human female
What's a female?
The ability to birth and feed children is the important part. You will never have that and thus never be a woman.
I don't get it, how did he know that his wife's answer was the right one if so many people before her gave him a different answer?
An adult human female.
That guy is a midwit
Write a whole book about transgenderism
It implies he did research
Goes on Rogan
"So how big of a problem this is, how many kids have been subjected to this ?"
MILLIONS !!!
"Holy shit, really ? Jamie, can you check ?"
"Apparently it's like a couple of thousands"
Oh, well, you know, I mean, erm, hm ...
Not saying it's OK if it's "just thousands" but Walsh is a typical American TikTok journalist who sources information from his ass
In the context of "an adult human female" what is a female?
A woman, duh
If you don't know what a woman is you won't understand the joke.
Get in the bin troon.
That's trolls from discworld
Zigger issuing opinion on women and science: the thread
The trannies are the ones begging the question moron.
THEY claim they are women. So you ask them since they are so sure they're women, what the fuck is a woman?
And they foam at the mouth with circular reasoning. That's the point of the film. It's something even biological women would have a hard time defining, so the only thing we can tell us for sure is your DNA and sex organs. Everything else is auxiliary. Like
"someone who likes to feel pretty". Ok, a man can like to feel pretty. He'd be a fruity/zesty man, but still a man etc. So the only one that is IMMUTABLE is the Chromosomes and Sex organs.
A really important part is that your definition is ad hoc.
Like in that famous example where an ancient philosopher defined a human as ‘a featherless biped.’ In response, one of his contemporaries plucked a rooster and, placing it before the philosopher, said, ‘Here is your human.’ The philosopher then amended his definition: ‘A featherless biped with nails.’"
Someone with XX Chromosomes and ideally is born with female sex organs like breasts and a vagina, but sometimes things can go wrong here in the womb.
This stuff is really confusing — especially when it comes to what a 'man' is. For the past three years, I’ve constantly heard that a man is ‘not just someone with balls and a dick, but someone who served in the army.’ It even rhymes in Russian.
Yet another casuistic open-ended definition for further ad hoc clarification. That’s unfortunate. In any case, it seems you don’t even understand the proper task - for some reason, you’re trying to invent a meaning for the word, rather than derive its meaning based on collected data about how the word is actually used.
You really need a woman G.
didnt watch but a good ending would have been him coming out as a woman
a meaning for the word, rather than derive its meaning based on collected data about how the word is actually used.
The mid 20th century called and they want their behaviorist trash back.
well no, no one ever said they're civilized. the point is that primitives despite their lack of knowledge instinctively know what a female is so questioning gender as a concept as though it can be separate from one's sex is ridiculous, so they laugh. he's visiting the far end of the bell curve to make the point that fringe academia becoming mainstream in the west has twisted the human condition.
so by your logic if everyone in this thread redefined the word 'faggot' to mean 'OP' you would be forced to comply, faggot?
There's nothing fucking confusing. You're born the sex/gender you are, that's it. Everything else is Auxillary. A man can wear a dress, be dainty, it's still a man. What makes a woman a woman is BIOLOGICAL. It's completely fucking measurable and DEFINITE.
Female is a reproductive sex class in mammals that are organized around the production of large immobile gametes typically called ovum. They gestate and nurse live young. You aren’t confused what a female horse is, you just have religious dogma where it’s demanded of you to pretend to not know that humans are also separated by sex the same as other mammals. You do you, bro, but your pain is fake and it means nothing to me.
This is absurd, as, among other things, the discovery of societies where gender does not always align with sex was one of the reasons for the separation of these concepts in the academic field
What is a woman
I don't know, my little peepee doesn't work so I guess everything is a man to me
anyone who thinks this movie presented a good argument btw answer me this: what is a car?
I don't know about the USA, but in Russia, if you're born with a penis and testicles, and someone pushes you in the street and calls you a woman, it's assumed that you should punch them in the face, not show them your documents with a male gender marker. This would cause laughter.
And how, in your view, one can determine the meaning of a word in a language they’re not familiar with, aside from observing how native speakers use it?
How in gods name does that relate what-so-ever to my comment or the OP question you fucking Neanderthal?
Chuds are redditors except with slightly less degenerate opinions. Almost equally annoying and toxic to society
This clearly illustrates that in Russia, being a man is not merely about possessing certain biological sex characteristics, but also about conforming to specific expectations regarding your behavior.
That's superficial. You're talking about masulinity/feminity, not being a woman/man. These are cultural, like how in a certain cultures there's rituals that a boy must go through before becoming a Man. This is what I was referring to when I say that a man can wear a dress, be dainty, and ultimately that's just a FEMININE man. Different cultures will have different words for it. Fag, fruit, maricon etc. But ultimately it's describing a MAN with feminine characteristics. The proof is that a WOMAN behaving this way, not called a "Fag", it's just a feminine women. But a Woman behaving manly/masculine is called a dyke/tomboy/stud etc. It's a WOMAN, with MASCULINE characteristics.
A self propelled mechanical device on four wheels with a cabin, that can transfer from one to multiple persons on the ground without the use of rails or similar structures
Yes, buses and trucks are also cars
This is absurd, it’s like saying that animals are a kingdom in the domain of eukaryotes. Then we land on another planet and see creatures that have tails, move on four legs, can't speak, and are no smarter than an earth cats, and we inevitably call them just animals, breaking the entire biological classification.
What stops you from remembering that people have been divided into men and women since time immemorial, while biological science only emerged relatively recently?
you’re trying to invent a meaning for the word, rather than derive its meaning based on collected data about how the word is actually used.
Is the latter method the only way that words are defined? No, it isn't.
magine asking for a car, and they bring you a bus instead. lol
It's not that complicated, retard. You can determine if a person is a woman or not by the DNA in a single skin cell.
1) You have to specify the car you want when you're renting
2) There are different types of a car just like with anything else
Imagine car rental ad with a pic of a Ferrari for 1000$ a day and they get you a Yugo - hey it's the same thing bro
So someone born with XXY is a woman?
don’t confuse 'definition' as in 'finding out' with 'definition' as in 'setting or assigning.'
We’re not trying to assign a meaning to the word, but to find out what meaning it alreay has.
Imagine you order a car, and they bring you a bus instead. And you're like, 'No big deal, it's my own fault.
Imagine paying for a Ferrari and getting a Yugo and going "well, a car is a car OK"
But Yago isn't even a Ferrari.
You were supposed to give an example of an 'unusual' Ferrari - one that isn’t a sports supercar from the famous Italian brand, which is the image that comes to mind for the vast majority of people when they hear the word 'Ferrari'.
Like how there are tractors by Porsche.
But Yago isn't even a Ferrari.
It's a car
Women haven't been invented yet.
Undeniable.